Season 1998 Edinburgh Div 3
2 Edin Univ 3 11 Civil Serv 4
0 Densmore Todd 0 - 1 MacCrae John 1265
0 Davies Anthony 0 - 1 Bridgeman Graham 1200
1130 Browning Craig 1 - 0 Gilroy Michael 1165
0 Godber Thomas 0 - 1 Beattie Alex J 1160
0 Weir Jonathan 0 - 1 Miller Kevin 1125
0 Powell David 0 - 1 Woods Brian 905
1 - 5
10 Portobello 3 Sandy Bells
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 0 - 1 Duncan Nicholas 1100
1095 Toal Ken (Snr) 0 - 1 Ward Peter James 1120
1080 Roberts Alan 1 - 0 Muir Lindsay 925
975 Tait Alan 0 - 1 MacLean Fiona 990
945 Harris Jim 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
935 Thomson Fergus J G ½ - ½ Flannigan Thomas 0
2½ - 3½
4 Lasswade 3 7 Corstorph 2
1430 MacIntosh Alan ½ - ½ Douglas Alexander G 1310
1390 Owens John ½ - ½ Gourlay Brian 1300
1125 Middleton Peter D 1 - 0 Ruthven Angus G 1210
0 Sarrazin Yann 0 - 1 Watson David 1185
1055 Shields John 0 - 1 Crerar Bruce 1000
960 Paxton Alex 0 - 1 Crerar James D 830
2 - 4
8 Wand Drag 5 12 Edin West 4
1420 Shapland David ½ - ½ Young Stanley M 1255
1405 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 Glynn M Ivor 1125
1350 Ritchie Stephen 1 - 0 Duncan Ian R 1050
1345 Harward Shaughan B 0 - 1 Crosbie Stewart 0
1290 Clarke Martin 0 - 1 Balfour John 1030
1245 Duncan Brian 1 - 0 Whitelaw James 1005
3½ - 2½
5 Badger Brook 6 Bank Scot 2
1455 Archer David 0 - 1 Murray Findlay R 1405
1250 Boylan Vincent ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1310
1250 Blythe Henry ½ - ½ Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1185
1190 Flannigan Jon 1 - 0 Anderson Douglas 1050
1175 Glidden Alistair 1 - 0 Main Ken 1045
1050 Liddle Robert ½ - ½ Melvin James 1040
3½ - 2½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 2
3 Sandy Bells 2 Edin Univ 3
0 Felipe R 0 - 1 Wright Fiona 1375
1120 Ward Peter James 0 - 1 Hill Martin 1245
1100 Duncan Nicholas 0 - 1 Browning Craig 1130
990 MacLean Fiona 0 - 1 O'Sullivan Stephen 1075
925 Muir Lindsay 1 - 0 Durie Ruth 0
0 Flannigan Thomas 1 - 0 MacGregor James 0
2 - 4
3 Sandy Bells 1 Livingston 2
1120 Ward Peter James 1 - 0 Dunsmore Alan 1325
1100 Duncan Nicholas 1 - 0 Ferguson Don 1290
925 Muir Lindsay 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1030 Wallace Mike 0 - 1 Marshall David 1275
0 Flannigan Thomas A - H Kerr Graham 1235 Away Win by Default
990 MacLean Fiona ½ - ½ Boyle Paul A 1230
3½ - 2½
7 Corstorph 2 1 Livingston 2
1325 Bruce Douglas 0 - 1 Dunsmore Alan 1325
1310 Douglas Alexander G 1 - 0 Wright Andrew 1285
1300 Gourlay Brian A - H Ferguson Don 1290 Away Win by Default
1210 Ruthven Angus G 0 - 1 Marshall David 1275
1005 Khosrowpour Peajmaan ½ - ½ Robinson Stuart 1255
830 Crerar James D 0 - 1 Kerr Graham 1235
1½ - 4½
9 Musselburgh3 12 Edin West 4
1415 MacFarlane Alex 1 - 0 Dunnett Andrew W 1310
1335 King David 1 - 0 Young Stanley M 1255
1255 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Dunnett Stuart W 1175
1225 Colquhoun William 1 - 0 Glynn M Ivor 1125
1210 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
1135 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Whitelaw James 1005
5 - 1
8 Wand Drag 5 5 Badger Brook
1420 Shapland David 0 - 1 Boylan Vincent 1250
1405 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
1350 Ritchie Stephen 1 - 0 Flannigan Jon 1190
1345 Harward Shaughan B 1 - 0 Glidden Alistair 1175
1280 MacIntosh Sally A 1 - 0 Liddle Robert 1050
0 Hardman Raymond ½ - ½ MacColl George 915
4½ - 1½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 3
10 Portobello 9 Musselburgh3
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 0 - 1 MacFarlane Alex 1415
1145 Howson David D 0 - 1 King David 1335
1095 Toal Ken (Snr) 0 - 1 Colquhoun William 1225
1080 Roberts Alan 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1210
945 Harris Jim 0 - 1 Stokes Eddie 1135
0 Boyle F 0 - 1 Knox David 1085
0 - 6
4 Lasswade 3 6 Bank Scot 2
1430 MacIntosh Alan 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1405
1390 Owens John ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1310
0 Sarrazin Yann 0 - 1 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1185
0 Fitchett Cyril 1 - 0 Turner James 0
1055 Shields John 0 - 1 Main Ken 1045
960 Paxton Alex ½ - ½ Melvin James 1040
3 - 3
10 Portobello 11 Civil Serv 4
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 0 - 1 MacCrae John 1265
1145 Howson David D 1 - 0 Bridgeman Graham 1200
1095 Toal Ken (Snr) ½ - ½ Gilroy Michael 1165
975 Tait Alan 0 - 1 Miller Kevin 1125
945 Harris Jim 1 - 0 Weston Derek F 995
935 Thomson Fergus J G 1 - 0 Woods Brian 905
3½ - 2½
5 Badger Brook 12 Edin West 4
1455 Archer David 0 - 1 Dunnett Andrew W 1310
1250 Boylan Vincent ½ - ½ Young Stanley M 1255
1250 Blythe Henry 1 - 0 Crosbie Stewart 0
1190 Flannigan Jon 1 - 0 Duncan Ian R 1050
1050 Liddle Robert 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
915 MacColl George 1 - 0 Whitelaw James 1005
4½ - 1½
3 Sandy Bells 4 Lasswade 3
1120 Ward Peter James 0 - 1 MacIntosh Alan 1430
1100 Duncan Nicholas 0 - 1 Owens John 1390
925 Muir Lindsay 0 - 1 MacArdle Malcolm 1305
1030 Wallace Mike 1 - 0 Middleton Peter D 1125
990 MacLean Fiona 1 - 0 Shields John 1055
0 Hewitt John ½ - ½ Paxton Alex 960
2½ - 3½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 4
11 Civil Serv 4 1 Livingston 2
1265 MacCrae John ½ - ½ Dunsmore Alan 1325
1235 Powell Alex 0 - 1 Ferguson Don 1290
1200 Bridgeman Graham 1 - 0 Robinson Stuart 1255
1165 Gilroy Michael 0 - 1 Kerr Graham 1235
1125 Miller Kevin 1 - 0 Boyle Paul A 1230
995 Weston Derek F 1 - 0 Scott Douglas 1070
3½ - 2½
2 Edin Univ 3 9 Musselburgh3
1725 Peddi N Choudary 1 - 0 MacFarlane Alex 1415
1245 Hill Martin 1 - 0 King David 1335
1130 Browning Craig 1 - 0 Montgomery Jim 1255
0 Weir Jonathan 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1210
0 Neville Joshi ½ - ½ Stokes Eddie 1135
0 MacGregor James ½ - ½ Knox David 1085
4 - 2
5 Badger Brook 7 Corstorph 2
1250 Boylan Vincent 0 - 1 Douglas Alexander G 1310
1250 Blythe Henry 1 - 0 Gourlay Brian 1300
1190 Flannigan Jon 0 - 1 Ruthven Angus G 1210
1175 Glidden Alistair 1 - 0 Watson David 1185
1050 Liddle Robert 1 - 0 Crerar Bruce 1000
915 MacColl George 1 - 0 Crerar James D 830
4 - 2
11 Civil Serv 4 4 Lasswade 3
1265 MacCrae John 0 - 1 MacIntosh Alan 1430
1200 Bridgeman Graham 0 - 1 Owens John 1390
1165 Gilroy Michael 1 - 0 Morran George 0
1160 Beattie Alex J ½ - ½ Middleton Peter D 1125
995 Weston Derek F 0 - 1 Shields John 1055
925 O'Donnell Brian 1 - 0 Paxton Alex 960
2½ - 3½
2 Edin Univ 3 8 Wand Drag 5
1375 Wright Fiona 1 - 0 Shapland David 1420
1130 Browning Craig 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1405
1075 O'Sullivan Stephen 1 - 0 Duncan Brian 1245
0 Durie Ruth 1 - 0 Hardman Raymond 0
1245 Hill Martin H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
0 Weir Jonathan H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
5 - 1
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 5
6 Bank Scot 2 3 Sandy Bells
1405 Murray Findlay R 1 - 0 Duncan Nicholas 1100
1360 Murray Robin H 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
1310 Ferrie Louis C 1 - 0 MacLean Fiona 990
1045 Main Ken 0 - 1 Muir Lindsay 925
1040 Melvin James 1 - 0 Flannigan Thomas 0
0 Edwards Colin 0 - 1 Hewitt John 0
4 - 2
1 Livingston 2 9 Musselburgh3
1325 Dunsmore Alan 1 - 0 King David 1335
1290 Ferguson Don 1 - 0 Montgomery Jim 1255
1275 Marshall David 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1210
1255 Robinson Stuart 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1135
1235 Kerr Graham 1 - 0 Knox David 1085
1230 Boyle Paul A H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
6 - 0
12 Edin West 4 10 Portobello
1310 Dunnett Andrew W 1 - 0 Dunnett Ronald J 1270
1175 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Roberts Alan 1080
1125 Glynn M Ivor 0 - 1 Tait Alan 975
0 Archibald S 1 - 0 Harris Jim 945
1030 Balfour John H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1005 Whitelaw James H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
4 - 2
11 Civil Serv 4 6 Bank Scot 2
1265 MacCrae John 1 - 0 Murray Findlay R 1405
1200 Bridgeman Graham 0 - 1 Murray Robin H 1360
1165 Gilroy Michael 0 - 1 Ferrie Louis C 1310
995 Weston Derek F 1 - 0 Goldie Martin 1270
905 Woods Brian 1 - 0 Main Ken 1045
Not Given A - H Melvin James 1040 Away Win by Default
3 - 3
10 Portobello 5 Badger Brook
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 1 - 0 Boylan Vincent 1250
975 Tait Alan 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
945 Harris Jim 1 - 0 Flannigan Jon 1190
935 Thomson Fergus J G 1 - 0 Glidden Alistair 1175
850 Marr Ian ½ - ½ MacColl George 915
Not Given A - H Liddle Robert 1050 Away Win by Default
4½ - 1½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 6
7 Corstorph 2 3 Sandy Bells
1310 Douglas Alexander G 0 - 1 France R 1745
1300 Gourlay Brian 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
1210 Ruthven Angus G 0 - 1 MacLean Fiona 990
1185 Watson David 0 - 1 Muir Lindsay 925
830 Crerar James D H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
1000 Crerar Bruce H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
3 - 3
9 Musselburgh3 4 Lasswade 3
1415 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 MacIntosh Alan 1430
1255 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Middleton Peter D 1125
1225 Colquhoun William 1 - 0 Morran George 0
1210 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Shields John 1055
1135 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Paxton Alex 960
1085 Knox David 0 - 1 Sarrazin Yann 0
3 - 3
8 Wand Drag 5 10 Portobello
1420 Shapland David 0 - 1 Dunnett Ronald J 1270
1405 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 Toal Ken (Snr) 1095
1350 Ritchie Stephen 1 - 0 Roberts Alan 1080
1280 Milne Jake 0 - 1 Harris Jim 945
1280 MacIntosh Sally A 0 - 1 Sivell D 0
1245 Duncan Brian 1 - 0 Toal Ken (Jnr) 935
3 - 3
7 Corstorph 2 11 Civil Serv 4
1325 Bruce Douglas 1 - 0 MacCrae John 1265
1310 Douglas Alexander G 1 - 0 Gilbert Robert 1250
1210 Ruthven Angus G 0 - 1 Bridgeman Graham 1200
1185 Watson David 0 - 1 Gilroy Michael 1165
1000 Crerar Bruce 1 - 0 Woods Brian 905
830 Crerar James D 1 - 0 Glover Derek 0
4 - 2
4 Lasswade 3 8 Wand Drag 5
1430 MacIntosh Alan ½ - ½ Shapland David 1420
1390 Owens John 1 - 0 Ritchie Stephen 1350
1125 Middleton Peter D 1 - 0 Milne Jake 1280
0 Morran George 0 - 1 MacIntosh Sally A 1280
1055 Shields John 0 - 1 Duncan Brian 1245
960 Paxton Alex 1 - 0 Hardman Raymond 0
3½ - 2½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 7
1 Livingston 2 12 Edin West 4
1325 Dunsmore Alan 1 - 0 Young Stanley M 1255
1290 Ferguson Don ½ - ½ Archibald S 0
1275 Marshall David 0 - 1 Crosbie Stewart 0
1255 Robinson Stuart 1 - 0 Knowles Mark 1135
1235 Kerr Graham 1 - 0 Duncan Ian R 1050
1230 Boyle Paul A 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
4½ - 1½
9 Musselburgh3 6 Bank Scot 2
1415 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 Murray Findlay R 1405
1255 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Murray Robin H 1360
1225 Colquhoun William ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1310
1210 Hope Iain D 0 - 1 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1185
1135 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Anderson Douglas 1050
1085 Knox David 1 - 0 Main Ken 1045
2½ - 3½
10 Portobello 2 Edin Univ 3
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 0 - 1 Wright Fiona 1375
1145 Howson David D 1 - 0 Hill Martin 1245
1095 Toal Ken (Snr) 0 - 1 Browning Craig 1130
1080 Roberts Alan 1 - 0 O'Sullivan Stephen 1075
975 Tait Alan 1 - 0 Weir Jonathan 0
945 Harris Jim 1 - 0 MacGregor James 0
4 - 2
3 Sandy Bells 5 Badger Brook
1745 France R 1 - 0 Boylan Vincent 1250
1100 Duncan Nicholas 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
1120 Ward Peter James 1 - 0 Flannigan Jon 1190
990 MacLean Fiona 1 - 0 Glidden Alistair 1175
1030 Wallace Mike 0 - 1 Liddle Robert 1050
0 Flannigan Thomas 0 - 1 MacColl George 915
4 - 2
7 Corstorph 2 2 Edin Univ 3
1325 Bruce Douglas 1 - 0 Wesiack Jan 0
1310 Douglas Alexander G 0 - 1 Nathan Siva 1395
1300 Gourlay Brian 0 - 1 Hill Martin 1245
1185 Watson David 0 - 1 O'Sullivan Stephen 1075
1000 Crerar Bruce 0 - 1 Weir Jonathan 0
830 Crerar James D 0 - 1 Durie Ruth 0
1 - 5
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 8
4 Lasswade 3 12 Edin West 4
1430 MacIntosh Alan 1 - 0 Dunnett Andrew W 1310
1390 Owens John 1 - 0 Dunnett Stuart W 1175
1125 Middleton Peter D 0 - 1 Knowles Mark 1135
0 Morran George 0 - 1 Glynn M Ivor 1125
1055 Shields John 1 - 0 Balfour John 1030
960 Paxton Alex 1 - 0 Whitelaw James 1005
4 - 2
3 Sandy Bells 11 Civil Serv 4
1745 France R 1 - 0 MacCrae John 1265
1100 Duncan Nicholas 1 - 0 Bridgeman Graham 1200
1120 Ward Peter James 1 - 0 Gilroy Michael 1165
990 MacLean Fiona 0 - 1 Miller Kevin 1125
925 Muir Lindsay 0 - 1 Mohammed Glen 1010
1030 Wallace Mike 1 - 0 Woods Brian 905
4 - 2
8 Wand Drag 5 6 Bank Scot 2
1405 Pirrie Gregor 1 - 0 MacVey Ernie 1460
1280 Milne Jake 0 - 1 Murray Findlay R 1405
1245 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 Murray Robin H 1360
955 Laurie Margaret 0 - 1 Goldie Martin 1270
0 Hardman Raymond 0 - 1 Anderson Douglas 1050
Not Given A - H Main Ken 1045 Away Win by Default
1 - 5
2 Edin Univ 3 5 Badger Brook
1375 Wright Fiona 0 - 1 Archer David 1455
0 Wesiack Jan 0 - 1 Boylan Vincent 1250
0 Steiner Erich W 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
1245 Hill Martin 1 - 0 Flannigan Jon 1190
0 Weir Jonathan 0 - 1 Glidden Alistair 1175
0 Mason Zelda 0 - 1 MacColl George 915
2 - 4
9 Musselburgh3 7 Corstorph 2
1415 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 Gourlay Brian 1300
1335 King David ½ - ½ Ruthven Angus G 1210
1255 Montgomery Jim 0 - 1 Watson David 1185
1225 Colquhoun William ½ - ½ Crerar Bruce 1000
1135 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Crerar James D 830
1085 Knox David 1 - 0 Morton P 0
3 - 3
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 9
12 Edin West 4 2 Edin Univ 3
1310 Dunnett Andrew W 1 - 0 Maxwell Peter 0
1175 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Wright Fiona 1375
1135 Knowles Mark ½ - ½ Steiner Erich W 0
1125 Glynn M Ivor 0 - 1 Hill Martin 1245
1050 Duncan Ian R 0 - 1 Weir Jonathan 0
1005 Whitelaw James 1 - 0 MacGregor James 0
2½ - 3½
10 Portobello 1 Livingston 2
1270 Dunnett Ronald J 0 - 1 Dunsmore Alan 1325
1145 Howson David D 0 - 1 Kerr Graham 1235
1095 Toal Ken (Snr) 0 - 1 Ferguson Don 1290
975 Tait Alan 1 - 0 Marshall David 1275
945 Harris Jim 0 - 1 Robinson Stuart 1255
0 Sivell D 0 - 1 Davis Anton 0
1 - 5
11 Civil Serv 4 8 Wand Drag 5
1265 MacCrae John 0 - 1 Shapland David 1420
1200 Bridgeman Graham 0 - 1 Pirrie Gregor 1405
1165 Gilroy Michael ½ - ½ MacIntosh Sally A 1280
1160 Beattie Alex J ½ - ½ Milne Jake 1280
1125 Miller Kevin ½ - ½ Duncan Brian 1245
995 Weston Derek F 0 - 1 Hardman Raymond 0
1½ - 4½
1 Livingston 2 4 Lasswade 3
1325 Dunsmore Alan 1 - 0 MacIntosh Alan 1430
1235 Kerr Graham ½ - ½ Owens John 1390
1290 Ferguson Don 1 - 0 Middleton Peter D 1125
1285 Wright Andrew 0 - 1 Doyle Steven 1160
1255 Robinson Stuart 1 - 0 Shields John 1055
0 Davis Anton 1 - 0 Paxton Alex 960
4½ - 1½
12 Edin West 4 3 Sandy Bells
1310 Dunnett Andrew W 1 - 0 Ward Peter James 1120
1175 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Duncan Nicholas 1100
1135 Knowles Mark 0 - 1 Muir Lindsay 925
1050 Duncan Ian R 1 - 0 MacLean Fiona 990
1030 Balfour John ½ - ½ Wallace Mike 1030
1005 Whitelaw James H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
3½ - 2½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 10
6 Bank Scot 2 2 Edin Univ 3
1405 Murray Findlay R 0 - 1 Nathan Siva 1395
1360 Murray Robin H 1 - 0 Mason Zelda 0
1310 Ferrie Louis C 1 - 0 Hill Martin 1245
1270 Goldie Martin 0 - 1 Browning Craig 1130
1185 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 0 - 1 O'Sullivan Stephen 1075
1050 Anderson Douglas 0 - 1 Durie Ruth 0
2 - 4
7 Corstorph 2 10 Portobello
1325 Bruce Douglas ½ - ½ Dunnett Ronald J 1270
1310 Douglas Alexander G 1 - 0 Toal Ken (Snr) 1095
1300 Gourlay Brian 1 - 0 Roberts Alan 1080
1210 Ruthven Angus G 1 - 0 Harris Jim 945
1185 Watson David 1 - 0 Thomson Fergus J G 935
830 Crerar James D 0 - 1 Sivell D 0
4½ - 1½
5 Badger Brook 11 Civil Serv 4
1250 Boylan Vincent 0 - 1 MacCrae John 1265
1250 Blythe Henry 1 - 0 Gilbert Robert 1250
1190 Flannigan Jon 1 - 0 Bridgeman Graham 1200
1175 Glidden Alistair 0 - 1 Gilroy Michael 1165
1050 Liddle Robert 1 - 0 O'Donnell Brian 925
915 MacColl George 1 - 0 Glover Derek 0
4 - 2
4 Lasswade 3 10 Portobello
1430 MacIntosh Alan ½ - ½ Dunnett Ronald J 1270
1390 Owens John 1 - 0 Toal Ken (Snr) 1095
1125 Middleton Peter D 0 - 1 Roberts Alan 1080
0 Durand David 1 - 0 Tait Alan 975
1055 Shields John 0 - 1 Harris Jim 945
960 Paxton Alex ½ - ½ Thomson Fergus J G 935
3 - 3
9 Musselburgh3 5 Badger Brook
1415 MacFarlane Alex 1 - 0 Blythe Henry 1250
1335 King David ½ - ½ Boylan Vincent 1250
1225 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Flannigan Jon 1190
1210 Hope Iain D 1 - 0 Glidden Alistair 1175
1135 Stokes Eddie 1 - 0 Liddle Robert 1050
1085 Knox David 1 - 0 MacColl George 915
4½ - 1½
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 11
8 Wand Drag 5 7 Corstorph 2
1405 Pirrie Gregor ½ - ½ Douglas Alexander G 1310
1345 Harward Shaughan B 0 - 1 Gourlay Brian 1300
1280 MacIntosh Sally A 0 - 1 Watson David 1185
1280 Milne Jake 1 - 0 Crerar Bruce 1000
0 Hardman Raymond 1 - 0 Crerar James D 830
0 Amara Ravi 1 - 0 Morton P 0
3½ - 2½
6 Bank Scot 2 12 Edin West 4
1405 Murray Findlay R 1 - 0 Dunnett Andrew W 1310
1360 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Young Stanley M 1255
1310 Ferrie Louis C ½ - ½ Archibald S 0
1270 Goldie Martin 1 - 0 Knowles Mark 1135
1045 Main Ken ½ - ½ Balfour John 1030
1040 Melvin James 1 - 0 Whitelaw James 1005
4 - 2
2 Edin Univ 3 1 Livingston 2
0 Thompson Chris 0 - 1 Wright Paul 1400
1245 Hill Martin 0 - 1 Kerr Graham 1235
1130 Browning Craig ½ - ½ Ferguson Don 1290
0 Weir Jonathan ½ - ½ Davis Anton 0
0 Wesiack Jan 1 - 0 Robinson Stuart 1255
0 MacGregor James 0 - 1 Wright Andrew 1285
2 - 4
3 Sandy Bells 9 Musselburgh3
1120 Ward Peter James A - H King David 1335 Away Win by Default
1100 Duncan Nicholas ½ - ½ Montgomery Jim 1255
925 Muir Lindsay 0 - 1 Colquhoun William 1225
1030 Wallace Mike 1 - 0 Hope Iain D 1210
990 MacLean Fiona 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1135
0 Flannigan Thomas 1 - 0 Knox David 1085
3½ - 2½
6 Bank Scot 2 7 Corstorph 2
1405 Murray Findlay R 0 - 1 Douglas Alexander G 1310
1360 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Gourlay Brian 1300
1310 Ferrie Louis C 1 - 0 Ruthven Angus G 1210
1185 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1 - 0 Watson David 1185
1040 Melvin James 1 - 0 Crerar Bruce 1000
0 Edwards Colin 0 - 1 Crerar James D 830
3 - 3
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 12
5 Badger Brook 1 Livingston 2
1250 Boylan Vincent 0 - 1 Wright Paul 1400
1250 Blythe Henry ½ - ½ Dunsmore Alan 1325
1190 Flannigan Jon 0 - 1 Kerr Graham 1235
1175 Glidden Alistair 0 - 1 Wright Andrew 1285
1050 Liddle Robert 0 - 1 Robinson Stuart 1255
915 MacColl George 0 - 1 Boyle Paul A 1230
½ - 5½
2 Edin Univ 3 4 Lasswade 3
1375 Wright Fiona 0 - 1 MacIntosh Alan 1430
0 Wesiack Jan 0 - 1 Jarlow S 0
1130 Browning Craig 0 - 1 MacArdle Malcolm 1305
0 Weir Jonathan 1 - 0 Durand David 0
0 MacGregor James 1 - 0 Shields John 1055
Not Given A - H Paxton Alex 960 Away Win by Default
2 - 4
8 Wand Drag 5 3 Sandy Bells
1420 Shapland David 1 - 0 Ward Peter James 1120
1405 Pirrie Gregor 0 - 1 Duncan Nicholas 1100
1345 Harward Shaughan B 0 - 1 Muir Lindsay 925
1280 MacIntosh Sally A 1 - 0 Wallace Mike 1030
1245 Duncan Brian 0 - 1 MacLean Fiona 990
0 Amara Ravi 0 - 1 Flannigan Thomas 0
2 - 4
6 Bank Scot 2 10 Portobello
1360 Murray Robin H 0 - 1 Dunnett Ronald J 1270
1310 Ferrie Louis C 1 - 0 Toal Ken (Snr) 1095
1270 Goldie Martin 0 - 1 Roberts Alan 1080
1045 Main Ken ½ - ½ Tait Alan 975
1040 Melvin James 0 - 1 Harris Jim 945
0 Edwards Colin 0 - 1 Sivell D 0
1½ - 4½
11 Civil Serv 4 9 Musselburgh3
1265 MacCrae John 0 - 1 King David 1335
1200 Bridgeman Graham 0 - 1 Montgomery Jim 1255
1235 Powell Alex ½ - ½ Colquhoun William 1225
1165 Gilroy Michael 0 - 1 Hope Iain D 1210
1160 Beattie Alex J 1 - 0 Stokes Eddie 1135
995 Weston Derek F ½ - ½ Knox David 1085
2 - 4
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 13
12 Edin West 4 7 Corstorph 2
1310 Dunnett Andrew W 0 - 1 Gourlay Brian 1300
1255 Young Stanley M ½ - ½ Ruthven Angus G 1210
1175 Dunnett Stuart W 0 - 1 Watson David 1185
0 Crosbie Stewart 0 - 1 Crerar Bruce 1000
1125 Glynn M Ivor 1 - 0 Crerar James D 830
1005 Whitelaw James H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
2½ - 3½
4 Lasswade 3 5 Badger Brook
1430 MacIntosh Alan ½ - ½ Boylan Vincent 1250
0 Durand David 0 - 1 Blythe Henry 1250
1125 Middleton Peter D ½ - ½ Flannigan Jon 1190
1055 Shields John 0 - 1 Glidden Alistair 1175
960 Paxton Alex 0 - 1 Liddle Robert 1050
0 Barclay Edward 1 - 0 MacColl George 915
2 - 4
1 Livingston 2 6 Bank Scot 2
1325 Dunsmore Alan 1 - 0 Murray Robin H 1360
1235 Kerr Graham ½ - ½ Ferrie Louis C 1310
1290 Ferguson Don H - A Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1185 Home Win by Default
1285 Wright Andrew 1 - 0 Anderson Douglas 1050
1230 Boyle Paul A 1 - 0 Main Ken 1045
1255 Robinson Stuart H - A Not Given Home Win by Default
5½ - ½
9 Musselburgh3 8 Wand Drag 5
1415 MacFarlane Alex 0 - 1 Shapland David 1420
1255 Montgomery Jim ½ - ½ Pirrie Gregor 1405
1225 Colquhoun William 0 - 1 Harward Shaughan B 1345
1210 Hope Iain D ½ - ½ Duncan Brian 1245
1135 Stokes Eddie 0 - 1 Hardman Raymond 0
1085 Knox David A - H Amara Ravi 0 Away Win by Default
1 - 5
12 Edin West 4 11 Civil Serv 4
1310 Dunnett Andrew W 0 - 1 MacCrae John 1265
1255 Young Stanley M 1 - 0 Bridgeman Graham 1200
0 Archibald S 1 - 0 Gilroy Michael 1165
1125 Glynn M Ivor 0 - 1 Miller Kevin 1125
1050 Duncan Ian R 0 - 1 Weston Derek F 995
1005 Whitelaw James 1 - 0 Woods Brian 905
3 - 3
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 14
Table Order = M pts
----------Boards (6 per Match)--------
----Matches---- ---Played--- --Defaults-- -Score-
Pos Team P W L D Pts W L D W L D Bds %
1 1 Livingston 2 10 8 2 0 16 35 11 9 5 0 0 44½ 74
2 3 Sandy Bells 11 6 4 1 13 32 24 5 0 5 0 34½ 52
3 4 Lasswade 3 11 5 3 3 13 26 27 12 1 0 0 33 50
4 2 Edin Univ 3 11 6 5 0 12 30 28 5 2 1 0 34½ 52
5 5 Badger Brook 11 6 5 0 12 25 30 10 1 0 0 31 47
6 8 Wand Drag 5 10 5 4 1 11 25 22 9 1 3 0 30½ 51
7 7 Corstorph 2 11 4 4 3 11 26 28 8 2 2 0 32 48
8 6 Bank Scot 2 11 4 4 3 11 25 27 10 2 2 0 32 48
9 9 Musselburgh3 11 4 5 2 10 27 25 11 1 2 0 33½ 51
10 10 Portobello 11 4 5 2 10 26 30 7 0 3 0 29½ 45
11 11 Civil Serv 4 11 2 7 2 6 25 32 8 0 1 0 29 44
12 12 Edin West 4 11 2 8 1 5 18 36 8 4 0 0 26 39
-- -- -- -- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ----
Tots for x-check 130 56 56 18 130 320 320 102 19 19 0 390
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 15
Match Cross Table
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Pld Pts
1 Livingston 2 x 4 2½ 4½ 5½ 5½ 4½ 6 5 2½ 4½ 60 44½
2 Edin Univ 3 2 x 4 2 2 4 5 5 4 2 1 3½ 66 34½
3 Sandy Bells 3½ 2 x 2½ 4 2 3 4 3½ 3½ 4 2½ 66 34½
4 Lasswade 3 1½ 4 3½ x 2 3 2 3½ 3 3 3½ 4 66 33
5 Badger Brook ½ 4 2 4 x 3½ 4 1½ 1½ 1½ 4 4½ 66 31
6 Bank Scot 2 ½ 2 4 3 2½ x 3 5 3½ 1½ 3 4 66 32
7 Corstorph 2 1½ 1 3 4 2 3 x 2½ 3 4½ 4 3½ 66 32
8 Wand Drag 5 1 2 2½ 4½ 1 3½ x 5 3 4½ 3½ 60 30½
9 Musselburgh3 0 2 2½ 3 4½ 2½ 3 1 x 6 4 5 66 33½
10 Portobello 1 4 2½ 3 4½ 4½ 1½ 3 0 x 3½ 2 66 29½
11 Civil Serv 4 3½ 5 2 2½ 2 3 2 1½ 2 2½ x 3 66 29
12 Edin West 4 1½ 2½ 3½ 2 1½ 2 2½ 2½ 1 4 3 x 66 26
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 16
*** Team 1 Livingston 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7464 Dunsmore Alan 1325 LV 9 7
11834 Wright Andrew 1285 NEW LV 6 3
3896 Ferguson Don 1290 LV 9 7
9434 Marshall David 1275 LV 5 3
5831 Robinson Stuart 1255 LV 9 6½
10613 Kerr Graham 1235 LV 10 9
3258 Boyle Paul A 1230 LVBS 6 4½
7928 Scott Douglas 1070 LV 1 0
7544 Davis Anton 0 LVDF 3 2½
9587 Wright Paul 1400 J18 LVBK 2 2
*** Team 2 Edin Univ 3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12974 Densmore Todd 0 EU 1 0
12971 Davies Anthony 0 EU 1 0
8415 Browning Craig 1130 J18 EU 8 5½
12975 Godber Thomas 0 EU 1 0
12915 Weir Jonathan 0 EU 9 4½
12976 Powell David 0 EU 1 0
6730 Wright Fiona 1375 J18 PREU 6 4
12285 Hill Martin 1245 NEW EU 9 6
10788 O'Sullivan Stephen 1075 NEW EU 5 4
12972 Durie Ruth 0 EU 4 3
12973 MacGregor James 0 EU 6 1½
7721 Peddi N Choudary 1725 EU 1 1
13062 Neville Joshi 0 EU 1 ½
0 0 0 0
0 0 0 0
12970 Wesiack Jan 0 EU 4 1
6632 Nathan Siva 1395 J20 PAEU 2 2
11728 Steiner Erich W 0 EU 2 1½
12432 Mason Zelda 0 EU 2 0
10971 Maxwell Peter 0 J?? EU 1 0
12409 Thompson Chris 0 EU 1 0
*** Team 3 Sandy Bells ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12169 Ward Peter James 1120 NEW SB 9 4
12167 Duncan Nicholas 1100 NEW SB 10 6½
9444 Muir Lindsay 925 SB 10 6
9443 Wallace Mike 1030 NEW SB 10 3½
12426 Flannigan Thomas 0 SB 7 3½
10604 MacLean Fiona 990 NEW SBWD 11 6½
13068 Felipe R 0 SB 1 0
9442 Hewitt John 0 SB 2 1½
13069 France R 1745 SB 3 3
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 17
*** Team 4 Lasswade 3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
5092 MacIntosh Alan 1430 LS 11 8
11832 Owens John 1390 NEW LS 8 6½
5254 Middleton Peter D 1125 LS 9 4
13063 Sarrazin Yann 0 LS 3 1
8672 Shields John 1055 J16 LS 11 2
8664 Paxton Alex 960 J15 LS 11 4½
8356 Fitchett Cyril 0 LS 1 1
4952 MacArdle Malcolm 1305 LS 2 2
13064 Morran George 0 LS 4 0
11836 Doyle Steven 1160 J15 LS 1 1
13065 Durand David 0 LS 3 1
13066 Jarlow S 0 LS 1 1
12492 Barclay Edward 0 LS 1 1
*** Team 5 Badger Brook ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
10771 Archer David 1455 BX 3 1
10478 Boylan Vincent 1250 BXED 11 4
10772 Blythe Henry 1250 NEW BX 11 5
10479 Flannigan Jon 1190 BX 11 4½
10774 Glidden Alistair 1175 BX 10 4
10773 Liddle Robert 1050 BX 10 6½
10775 MacColl George 915 BX 10 6
*** Team 6 Bank Scot 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6910 Murray Findlay R 1405 BS 9 5
3909 Ferrie Louis C 1310 BS 10 7½
7947 Ahmadzedeh Ahmad 1185 BS 6 3½
11556 Anderson Douglas 1050 NEW BS 5 1
4836 Main Ken 1045 BS 9 3
11147 Melvin James 1040 BS 7 5
11731 Turner James 0 BS 1 0
5442 Murray Robin H 1360 BS 9 5
9836 Edwards Colin 0 BS 3 0
7023 Goldie Martin 1270 BS 5 2
5234 MacVey Ernie 1460 BSRB 1 0
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 18
*** Team 7 Corstorph 2 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
7095 Bruce Douglas 1325 CO 4 2½
3782 Douglas Alexander G 1310 CO 9 6
8390 Gourlay Brian 1300 CO 10 6½
5883 Ruthven Angus G 1210 COGS 9 3
11406 Khosrowpour Peajmaan 1005 J14 CO 1 ½
9746 Crerar James D 830 CO 11 4
9743 Watson David 1185 CO 10 5
10620 Crerar Bruce 1000 CO 9 4½
13072 Morton P 0 CO 2 0
*** Team 8 Wand Drag 5 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
12439 Shapland David 1420 EUWD 8 4
5643 Pirrie Gregor 1405 WDBS 9 7
9049 Ritchie Stephen 1350 PLWD 4 3
4294 Harward Shaughan B 1345 EDWD 5 2
6847 Clarke Martin 1290 J17 HCWD 1 0
9578 Duncan Brian 1245 SBWD 8 4
7712 MacIntosh Sally A 1280 WHWD 6 3½
12512 Hardman Raymond 0 WD 7 3½
7711 Milne Jake 1280 WD 5 1½
4652 Laurie Margaret 955 WD 1 0
13073 Amara Ravi 0 WD 3 2
*** Team 9 Musselburgh3 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9511 MacFarlane Alex 1415 MU 8 3
4596 King David 1335 MU 8 5
5330 Montgomery Jim 1255 MU 9 2
9509 Colquhoun William 1225 MU 9 5½
4379 Hope Iain D 1210 MU 10 6½
6140 Stokes Eddie 1135 MU 11 6½
11599 Knox David 1085 PLMU 10 5
Season 1998 ELCA Div 3 Cr 09/06/98 Proc 23/06/98 23/06/98 Page 19
*** Team 10 Portobello ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
9580 Dunnett Ronald J 1270 PL 11 4
11782 Toal Ken (Snr) 1095 NEW PL 9 ½
9761 Roberts Alan 1080 PL 8 5
8684 Tait Alan 975 PL 8 4½
8677 Harris Jim 945 PL 11 7
11421 Thomson Fergus J G 935 J17 ED 5 3
9765 Howson David D 1145 PL 4 2
13070 Boyle F 0 PL 1 0
8678 Marr Ian 850 PL 1 ½
13071 Sivell D 0 PL 4 3
11598 Toal Ken (Jnr) 935 NEW PL 1 0
*** Team 11 Civil Serv 4 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
8757 MacCrae John 1265 CS 11 5½
9033 Bridgeman Graham 1200 CS 11 3
11146 Gilroy Michael 1165 CS 11 4
3158 Beattie Alex J 1160 CS 4 3
10731 Miller Kevin 1125 J19 CSJG 6 5½
12391 Woods Brian 905 NEW CS 6 2
6440 Weston Derek F 995 CS 7 3½
5672 Powell Alex 1235 CS 2 ½
8243 O'Donnell Brian 925 CS 2 1
9178 Gilbert Robert 1250 CS 2 0
12620 Glover Derek 0 CS 2 0
12392 Mohammed Glen 1010 NEW CS 1 1
*** Team 12 Edin West 4 ***
PNum Name Grade Status Club Played Points
6573 Young Stanley M 1255 EW 7 3½
4105 Glynn M Ivor 1125 EW 7 2
3804 Duncan Ian R 1050 EW 6 1
12423 Crosbie Stewart 0 EW 4 2
3103 Balfour John 1030 EW 8 3
9054 Whitelaw James 1005 EW 10 5
7925 Dunnett Andrew W 1310 J19 EW 9 4
7926 Dunnett Stuart W 1175 EW 6 1
13067 Archibald S 0 EW 4 3
10605 Knowles Mark 1135 EW 5 1½